Newly Elected Lawmakers Must Reject ‘Medicare for All’

Ross Marchand

November 18, 2026

This op-ed was originally published in The Well News.

The votes are (mostly) counted, and the result is a sweeping change of power in Washington, D.C. Democrats scored significant Election Day victories, capturing control of both chambers of Congress and securing several high-profile wins in traditionally red states. 

Among the most consequential results was Democrat James Talarico’s victory over Republican Ken Paxton in Texas’ Senate race, marking the party’s first statewide victory in Texas in more than three decades. In Michigan, progressive Democrat Abdul El-Sayed defeated Republican Rep. Mike Rogers for an open U.S. Senate seat.

While the Democrats campaigned heavily on affordability, signs abound that they may not deliver. Until now, the budget-busting concept of “Medicare for All” has been nothing more than an item on the left-wing wish list. El-Sayed “literally wrote the book” on the idea and claims it’ll lead to a “healthier America,” while Talarico’s “Medicare for Y’all” would expand Medicare (traditionally for seniors) to all ages. Whatever one calls it, this idea would cost taxpayers tens of trillions of dollars while compromising health care access across the country.

Lawmakers should instead focus on rolling back regulatory barriers to health care freedom and advance choice.

The foundational promise of “Medicare for All” is that a single government payer can eliminate private insurance overhead and lower overall health care expenditures. In practice, removing cost-sharing mechanisms — such as copays, deductibles and premiums — eliminates price sensitivity for consumers. When care appears “free” at the point of delivery, demand surges exponentially.
 

Independent economic analyses repeatedly highlight the massive fiscal footprint of such a transition. Studies from institutions such as the Mercatus Center and the Urban Institute project that “Medicare for All” would increase federal government spending by $32 trillion to $34 trillion over its first 10 years.

Rather than curbing spending, centralized control creates a perpetual budgetary drain. Because political incentives favor expanding benefits over enforcing fiscal discipline, government spending under a single-payer regime tends to balloon far beyond initial forecasts.

“Medicare for All” proposals generally rely on lowering reimbursement rates to health care providers to match current Medicare fee schedules, which sit significantly below private insurance rates. Slashing reimbursement rates across the board while simultaneously increasing patient demand creates a severe supply-and-demand mismatch.

Hospitals and medical practices tend to operate on narrow margins. Forcing all care to be reimbursed at lower government rates would compel clinics to cut staffing, limit services or close altogether — particularly in rural and underserved areas. Physicians would face higher patient loads for reduced compensation, accelerating early retirements and discouraging top talent from entering the medical profession. The predictable result is not universal access to immediate treatment, but universal access to a waiting list. 

Moreover, existing experience in the U.S. demonstrates that government control over health care results in lackluster outcomes and an array of unintended consequences. For example, more than 2 million Native Americans receive care through the Indian Health Service, an agency within the Department of Health and Human Services. This small agency costs taxpayers an astounding $8 billion per year with lackluster results. While the government is well intentioned in attempting to directly provide care to Native Americans, the abysmal results speak to the fundamental failure of federal management of health care. 

Across 330 Indian land territories in the U.S., IHS directly foots the bill for hospitals and physicians and dictates the level and quality of care. According to its patients, this much-talked about “right” to health care amounts to very little in reality.

According to Victoria Kitcheyan of the Winnebago Tribe of Nebraska, Native Americans expecting decent, comprehensive quality of care will instead encounter “emergency room nurses who do not know how to administer such basic drugs as dopamine; employees who did not know how to call a Code Blue; an emergency room where defibrillators could not be found or utilized when a human life was at stake.”

It’s time to end, not expand, this failed experiment. The good news is there are far better approaches to health care reform offered by policymakers.

Republican Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul’s Health Marketplace and Savings Accounts for All Act would dramatically expand the availability of Health Savings Accounts, giving all Americans access to tax-free accounts. The legislation would also expand Association Health Plans to make it easier for Americans to use group leverage to keep costs down. 

Other commonsense regulatory reforms, such as ending the cap on physician-owned hospitals, reforming the Stark law, embracing Medicare site neutrality, allowing Americans to buy insurance across state lines, and pushing states to roll back certificate of need laws, would go a long way toward lowering costs and expanding access. 

“Medicare for All” would be a catastrophe for America and taxpayers, and the new Congress must avoid this bankrupt idea.